Sam Sifton’s Trini-Chinese Chicken (Trinidadian Chinese Five Spice Chicken)

trini chinese chicken closeup

This is my contribution to this month’s #LetsLunch, a monthly virtual potluck on Twitter.  This month’s theme is “munchies,” to toast the release of The Marijuana Chronicles, an anthology featuring a story by Cheryl Tan, one of the founders of #LetsLunch.  Here’s a recipe that will hit the spot when you’ve got the munchies– vibrantly flavored with smoky spice, heat, umami and a touch of sweetness.

*     *     *

I am a huge fan of Sam Sifton, of The New York Times, and love how he brings a lively story with every recipe he presents.  So I was excited when I saw his recent recipe for Trinidadian Chinese Chicken (“East Meets West Indies”).  His depiction of Trinidad is reminiscent of VS Naipaul‘s writing:

“The dish pays faint, mongrelized homage to the Chinese indentured servants who came to Trinidad in the 19th century to cut cane and harvest cacao when the British abolished African slavery but still needed chattel to do their work. The Chinese cooked their own food when they weren’t slaving. All Trinidad — not just Caribs and Africans but also, as in Derek Walcott’s description of the population, “the chained Cromwellian convict and the Sephardic Jew, the Chinese grocer and the Lebanese merchant selling cloth samples on his bicycle” — savored the result. Each group eventually made the cooking its collective own.”

My husband, whose grandfather came from Canton not as an indentured servant but who was, indeed, a Chinese grocer, was excited to see Trinidadian Chinese food, a lesser known cuisine in the US, featured in the NY Times.  But he steupsed— a Trini expression for sucking the teeth to express disdain– at the sauce Sifton made for the chicken:

“The addition of a Scotch-bonnet sauce (choose your own, but make sure it is fruity in its fire, with a rich aftertaste) to the funky salinity of a commercial Chinese oyster sauce is revelatory, a culinary mash-up of the very first order. Slathered on the crisp chicken, it becomes visible poetry, a joyous product of survival under hard odds.”

“What kind of sauce is that? It sounds like he just mixed together a little bit of this, a little bit of that,” is how my husband put it.  “You don’t do that in Trinidad.”

Still, I had to try.  I don’t actually remember eating this chicken with my in-laws, despite their being the-real-deal Chinese Trinidadians.  The result? PHENOMENAL.  Even my previously skeptical husband devoured it.  He said the chicken was like what his mother used to make.  And he admitted that the sauce, while not authentic, was surprisingly tasty.

*     *     *

Sam Sifton’s Trini-Chinese Chicken

Recipe from the New York Times Magazine March 31, 2013

Serves 4 to 6


8 to 10 chicken thighs, legs and wings, about 2 1/2 to 3 pounds total
2 tablespoons five-spice powder
3 limes
3 tablespoons soy sauce
1 2-inch knob ginger root, peeled and minced
1/2 cup neutral oil, like canola or grapeseed
2 tablespoons sesame oil
1/2 cup oyster sauce
1 to 3 tablespoons Scotch-bonnet-pepper sauce, ideally Matouk’s Soca, to taste
Freshly ground black pepper
1/4 cup chopped scallions, for garnish.


1.  In a large, nonreactive bowl, toss the chicken with five-spice powder, then with the juice of 2 of the limes, the soy sauce and the ginger. Cover and marinate in the refrigerator for at least 30 minutes and up to 6 hours.
2.  Heat oils in a large skillet over medium-high heat. There should be at least 1/4 inch of oil in the pan. When the oil is hot, remove chicken from marinade, allowing excess marinade to drip back into the bowl, and fry, in batches if necessary to not crowd the pan, turning the pieces frequently, until well browned and cooked through, 15 to 20 minutes.
3.  Meanwhile, make the dipping sauce. Combine oyster sauce, a tablespoon of the Scotch-bonnet-pepper sauce and the juice of the remaining lime and stir to combine. Adjust seasonings with more hot sauce, lime juice and freshly ground black pepper to taste.
4.  Garnish with scallions and serve with white or fried rice, with a drizzle of the sauce over each piece of chicken and the remaining sauce on the side.

sifton sauce

Please check back later for a list of all the contributions from the #LetsLunch food bloggers and writers around the globe.  Thanks for coming by! If you enjoyed this, please comment and/or share with your friends.

Annabelle‘s Scallion Pancakes at Glass of Fancy

Anne Marie‘s Pepper-Stuffed Tater Tot, Fried Pickle, Cheese Whiz and Garlic Bread Burger at Sandwich Surprise

Cheryl’s Spam Fries with Key Lime Dip at A Tiger in the Kitchen

Emma‘s Homemade Pizza Rolls at Dreaming of Pots and Pans

Grace‘s Fry Sauce, with an Asian Twist at HapaMama

Jonathan‘s Chocolate Chewy Squares at Jonathan Santlofer

Linda‘s Heavenly Hash Popcorn at Free Range Cookies

Lisa‘s No-Time-To-Wait Nachos at Monday Morning Cooking Club

Pat‘s Sausage Rolls at The Asian Grandmothers Cookbook

Rashda‘s Farm-Fresh Corn Fritters at Hot Curries & Cold Beer

Vivian‘s Spam Bacon & Kim Chi Sandwich at Vivian Pei


23 responses

  1. Pingback: Glass of Fancy » Blog Archive » Let’s Lunch: Scallion Pancakes - Fashion, fiction, and life in the city.

  2. Pingback: The Tot Head: A Simple Sandwich For The Munchies | sandwich surprise!

  3. Holy cow — these look so good! They’ve got all the flavors I adore. (And I love Sam Sifton’s recipes, too!) Can’t wait to try … thanks for sharing!

    • I think you’ll love this. The lime juice does some alchemy, adds a different and very good dimension to the five spice. And I just realized I posted this the same day the NYT announced Sam Sifton’s return to Food, yay!

  4. Pingback: Munchie Mania: Sausage Rolls | The Asian Grandmothers Cookbook

  5. Pingback: Heavenly Hash Popcorn

    • Sam Sifton was the NYT dining editor until 2 years ago, when he was transferred for the National desk. He has continued to write about food in the NYT Magazine. Coincidentally on the day I posted this, he just announced that he is moving back to a new food opportunity at the NYT! So you’ll see a lot more of him.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s